Stay Informed
iLeasePro Newsletter

Expert Knowledge to Your Inbox - SignUp Now!

Understanding the Definition of a Lease Under ASC 842

John Meedzan


The Financial Accounting Standards Board (“FASB”) and the International Accounting Standards Board (“IASB”) (collectively, “the Boards”) met earlier this week to continue their deliberations on the Joint Lease Accounting Project. The meeting focused specifically on the definition of a lease and the Boards reiterated the conclusions that they had reached in their Joint Meeting in October 2014. Apparently the discussion on this specific topic has been concluded.

The Boards have decided that a lease must embody the following characteristics:


  • Contract that conveys the right to use a specific asset (underlying asset) for a period of time;

  • Exchange of consideration;

  • Use of an identified asset either explicitly or implicitly specified; and

  • Contract conveys to the customer the right to control the use of the identified asset through the term of the use.

Note that if the supplier has a substantive right to substitute the asset, then the contract would not involve the use of a specific asset. A substantive right is one where the supplier has the practical ability to make the substitution and benefits from the substitution.

Note also that right to control means that the customer has the right to both direct the use of the asset and obtain substantially all of the economic benefit from the asset during the period of use.

The Boards decided against requiring that the customer would have to direct the use of the asset on its own or together with other resources.

Although the deliberations have concluded, there undoubtedly will be questions regarding how this definition will be applied in practice to certain contractual arrangements. For example, there was a recent discussion in the Lease Administration section of LinkedIn which described a contractual arrangement for what can be characterized as “hoteled” office space. In this case the user contracts for use of office space of a certain type but there may well not be any specific identified asset. The supplier has the right to move the customer to a number of locations (substitution) and the customer does not have control of a specific, identified asset. The consensus of those commenting was that this arrangement did not meet the definition of a lease as proposed by the Boards and would be accounted for as a service arrangement. However, this conclusion is only the opinion of those commenting and it is not clear how the Boards would view this arrangement.

It will be important for the Boards to include specific examples in the final standard that will assist in clarifying how the definition of a lease will be applied in practice. In any case, this will continue to be a challenging aspect of implementation.




Related: iLeasePro Free Trial, iLeaseXpress, iLeaseXpress Unlimited, ASC 842 Financial Reporting, ASC 842 Balance Sheet Reporting, ASC 842 Income Statement Reporting, ASC 842 Cash Flow Reporting, ASC 842 Statement of Shareholder Equity, ASC 842 Disclosure Notes, ASC 842 Management Discussion, ASC 842 Comprehensive Income, ASC 842 Glossary of Terms, ASC 842 Journal Entries, ASC 842 Software, When Is the ASC 842 Compliance Date, FASB Lease Accounting Software, Understanding the New FASB ASC 842 Lease Accounting Standard, How Does a Lease Balance Sheet Change After the New Standard?, Tracking Lease Details After ASC 842, Deferred Rent Explained Under the ASC 842, Guide to Lease Classification, Overview of Relevant Borrowing Rate, ASC 842 Footnote Disclosure, Lease Accounting, What Does Lease Accounting Software Do?, Key Features of A Lease Accounting Software, How to Never Miss Important Lease Dates, Scaling Your Lease Accounting Software to Your Business Needs, How to Select the Right Lease Solution, How to Set Up Lease Accounting Software, What is the Best Lease Accounting Software?, Overview of the Types of Leases, Equipment Lease Software, How the Right Lease Management Software Makes Equipment Leases Easier, Lease Tracking Software, How The Right Software Can Help You Manage Lease Data, Five Benefits of a SaaS Lease Management Solution, A Centralized Lease Portfolio Making Asset Management Easier, Lease Analysis 101, Lease Analysis: The Financial Metrics, Lease Abstraction, The Importance of Lease Abstraction for Lessees, The Lease Data an Abstract Should Include, What Software Do I Need for Lease Abstracting?, Navigating The ASC 842 Accounting Audit, Ultimate Lease Accounting Audit Checklist, Essential Guide To Engaging Auditors, Leveraging AI for Enhanced Year-End Audits Transitioning to the ASC 842 Standard Lease Document Management ASC 842 Short-Term Leases Practical Expedients Lease Modifications & Remeasurements Lease Variable Payments Embedded Leases Monitoring Critical Lease Dates Transportation - Navigate the ASC 842 The Impact of the ASC 842 on Regulatory Policies in Lease Management & Lease Accounting Integrating Lease Accounting into Your Month-End Closing Process The Modified Retrospective Approach in ASC 842 Determining the Incremental Borrowing Rate